Hi, How Can We Help You?

The Best Prescott Criminal Defense Lawyer (2025)

    FREE CONSULTATION

    Ted Agnick, An Experienced Criminal Lawyer in Prescott, AZ on Court TV

    Criminal Case Types I Handle

    When you’re searching for a Prescott Criminal Defense Lawyer, it’s important to work with someone who has real experience with your specific type of charge. You don’t want to be a lawyer’s first DUI, assault, or domestic violence client.

    At Prescott.lawyer, I handle a wide range of criminal cases, including but not limited to:

    • DUI and DUI accidents

    • Drug crimes (possession, sales, paraphernalia)

    • Sex crimes

    • Violent crimes

    • Domestic violence offenses

    • Endangerment

    • Homicide and serious felony offenses

    • Firearm and weapons crimes

    • Theft and shoplifting

    • White-collar crimes

    • Juvenile offenses

    • Property crimes (burglary, criminal damage, trespassing)

    • Expungements, set asides, and appeals

    • Disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace

    This is not a complete list of the cases I handle, but it reflects the breadth of my criminal defense practice. Whether you’re facing an infraction, misdemeanor, or felony, I can evaluate your situation and explain your options.

    If you’re unsure whether I handle your type of charge, contact me for a free initial consultation. I’ll review your case, answer your questions, and let you know how I can help.


    Prescott Criminal Case Classifications

    Understanding how your charge is classified under Arizona law is crucial because it directly affects the potential penalties you face. In Arizona, criminal offenses are generally divided into three categories:

    Felonies

    Felonies are the most serious type of offense. They often involve significant harm, use of weapons, or large financial loss. Examples include aggravated assault, robbery, child abuse, fraud, and certain sex offenses.

    • Felony convictions typically carry more than one year in prison.

    • Some felonies can lead to decades in prison, life sentences, or in rare cases, the death penalty.

    • Felonies can also result in long-term consequences such as losing civil rights, including the right to possess firearms.

    Misdemeanors

    Misdemeanors are less serious than felonies, but still carry meaningful penalties.

    • In Arizona, most misdemeanors carry up to one year in jail.

    • Punishments can include jail, fines, probation, community service, classes, counseling, and house arrest.

    • Common misdemeanors include many DUI charges, some domestic violence offenses, and lower-level theft or disorderly conduct.

    Infractions

    Infractions are minor offenses, often involving traffic violations or regulatory issues.

    • They are usually not treated as full criminal charges.

    • Penalties are typically limited to fines and do not include jail time in most cases.

    • Even so, infractions can still have financial and collateral consequences.

    No matter how your case is classified, it’s important to take it seriously. Even a “minor” offense can affect your finances, your driving record, your employment, and your future opportunities. If you’re facing a felony in Prescott or anywhere in Yavapai County, it is especially critical to speak with a qualified Prescott criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible so we can begin building your defense.


    What to Look for in a Prescott Valley Criminal Defense Lawyer

    The lawyer you choose can have a significant impact on how your case turns out. When you’re searching for a criminal defense lawyer in Prescott Valley, AZ, here are key factors to consider:

    Specialized Criminal Defense Experience

    Look for a lawyer who focuses on criminal law and has handled cases similar to yours. DUI, domestic violence, sex crimes, white-collar offenses, and violent felonies each require different strategies and knowledge. You want someone who already understands the laws and defenses that apply to your type of charge.

    Proven Track Record

    Research the attorney’s results and reputation. A history of dismissals, reduced charges, favorable plea agreements, and strong trial outcomes shows that the lawyer knows how to get results. For example, I have extensive experience and a strong record in DUI cases and other serious criminal matters in Yavapai County.

    Resources and Preparation

    Effective criminal defense often requires investigation, expert witnesses, document review, and careful preparation. Ask how the lawyer approaches building a case and what resources they use to challenge the prosecution’s evidence.

    Reputation and Reviews

    Client reviews, testimonials, and referrals can tell you a lot about how an attorney practices law. Look for feedback about communication, honesty, professionalism, and results. A solid reputation in the community and among former clients is an important indicator of reliability.

    Local Knowledge

    Hiring a lawyer familiar with Prescott, Prescott Valley, and the local courts is a major advantage. Local knowledge means a better understanding of:

    • How specific judges handle cases

    • How local prosecutors approach plea offers

    • The procedures and expectations in each courthouse

    This insight helps shape a realistic and effective defense strategy.

    Communication and Clarity

    You should feel comfortable asking questions and getting clear, straightforward answers. Your lawyer should:

    • Listen to your concerns

    • Explain your options in plain language

    • Keep you updated on important developments

    • Respond to calls and messages in a reasonable time

    Good communication helps you make informed decisions about your case.

    Personalized Strategy

    No two cases are the same. A good Prescott criminal defense lawyer will take the time to learn about your background, your goals, and the details of your situation. Your defense plan should be tailored to you — not a one-size-fits-all approach.

    Prescott Criminal Defense Lawyer With 29 Years of Proven Results

    If you’ve been arrested or accused of a crime in Prescott or Prescott Valley, securing the right Prescott Criminal Defense Lawyer may be the most important decision you make. Arizona enforces some of the strictest criminal laws in the country, and even a first-time offense can jeopardize your job, reputation, freedom, and future.

    With 29 years of experience, I provide focused, personalized, and strategic defense for individuals facing DUI charges, domestic violence allegations, drug-related offenses, assault, theft, disorderly conduct, and serious felony accusations in Yavapai County.

    At Prescott.lawyer, you work directly with an experienced attorney from the beginning of your case until the final resolution. Your defense is never handed off, and your future is never treated as “just another file.”


    Facing Criminal Charges in Prescott? Here’s What You Should Know

    Criminal enforcement is aggressive throughout the Tri-City region. During Labor Day Weekend alone, the Tri-City DUI Task Force reported 729 violations and 12 DUI arrests across Prescott, Prescott Valley, and Chino Valley.

    The task force includes:

    • Prescott Police Department

    • Prescott Valley Police Department

    • Chino Valley Police Department

    • Yavapai County Sheriff’s Office

    • Arizona Department of Public Safety

    Being charged isn’t unusual — but failing to respond properly can change your life.


    Act Immediately: Protect Your Rights After an Arrest

    If you’re arrested in Arizona, the most important action you can take is to use your Miranda Rights.

    You should:

    • Remain silent. You are legally required to give only your name.

    • Decline questioning until you have an attorney present.

    • Avoid offering explanations — they can and will be used against you.

    • Refuse interviews without legal counsel.

    • Decline searches or tests you are not required to take under Arizona law.

    • Cooperate physically during the arrest to avoid additional charges.

    Once you call my office, I step in immediately to protect your constitutional rights, prevent self-incrimination, and guide you through the next steps.


    Consequences of Not Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer

    Without experienced representation, you risk:

    • Jail time

    • License suspension

    • Mandatory classes and treatment programs

    • Loss of employment due to court obligations

    • Being pressured into accepting an unfair plea deal

    • Accidental self-incrimination

    • Years of interlock requirements (DUI cases)

    • A permanent criminal record that impacts housing and future opportunities

    Early legal intervention often leads to significantly better outcomes.


    Why Clients Trust Prescott.lawyer

    For nearly three decades, we have dedicated our legal practice exclusively to criminal defense. Clients choose me because they want:

    • Direct representation from an experienced attorney

    • Clear communication and responsive guidance

    • A defense tailored to their unique circumstances

    • A lawyer who knows the local courts and prosecutors

    • A strategic, evidence-driven approach

    • An advocate who fights for dismissals, reductions, and acquittals

    When your future is on the line, experience and personal attention make all the difference.


    Courts Served Throughout Yavapai County

    Prescott Valley Magistrate Court

    7501 Civic Cir #122, Prescott Valley, AZ 86314
    Handles civil traffic violations, protective orders, and misdemeanor charges including DUI, domestic violence, and theft.

    Camp Verde Superior Court (Yavapai County Superior Court)

    120 South Cortez Street, Prescott, AZ 86303
    Handles felony criminal matters and major cases countywide.

    Prescott Justice Court / Prescott City Court (Prescott Consolidated Court)

    120 South Cortez Street, Room 103, Prescott, AZ 86303
    Limited jurisdiction court overseeing misdemeanors, traffic violations, and protective orders.

    Verde Valley Justice Center

    10 South 6th Street, Cottonwood, AZ 86326
    Handles misdemeanors, traffic violations, and protective orders for Cottonwood, Camp Verde, Jerome, and half of Sedona.

    Seligman Justice Court

    54150 Floyd Street, Seligman, AZ 86337
    Jurisdiction includes misdemeanor offenses and traffic violations for Seligman and Ash Fork.

    Mayer Justice Court

    12840 Central Avenue, Mayer, AZ
    Covers Bumble Bee, Black Canyon City, Crown King, Humboldt, Dewey, Cleator, and Mayer.

    Bagdad/Yarnell Justice Court

    22591 Looka Way, Yarnell, AZ
    Handles misdemeanor and traffic cases in Bagdad, Yarnell, Congress, Wilhoit, Kirkland, and Peeples Valley.

    Understanding local courts — their processes, tendencies, and judicial expectations — provides a significant advantage when building a defense.


    How a Prescott Criminal Defense Lawyer Protects You

    As your attorney, I:

    • Work to stop immediate license suspension (when applicable)

    • Examine every detail of your arrest for legal errors

    • Gather critical evidence to strengthen your defense

    • Challenge improper police procedures

    • Identify constitutional violations

    • Negotiate for charge reductions or dismissals

    • Conduct hearings and trial representation

    • Cross-examine witnesses and challenge unreliable evidence

    Our mission is simple: fight for the best possible outcome, whether that’s a dismissal, reduced charge, or a not-guilty verdict.


    Our Approach to Criminal Defense

    Every client’s life is different, and every case impacts their future in its own way. I built my practice around:

    • Transparency

    • Preparation

    • Early intervention

    • Proactive strategy

    • Personalized service

    • Clear, consistent communication

    When you call Prescott.lawyer, you speak directly with the attorney who will handle your case from start to finish.


    Frequently Asked Questions

    1. What should I do immediately after being arrested in Prescott?

    Remain silent, request an attorney, and avoid making statements. Contact my office as soon as possible.

    2. Can you get my charges dismissed?

    Dismissals are possible depending on evidence, police procedure, and constitutional issues. Every case is evaluated individually.

    3. Do I need a lawyer for a first-time DUI?

    Absolutely. Arizona has some of the toughest DUI penalties in the country, even for first offenses.

    4. How much will a criminal defense lawyer cost?

    Fees vary based on the complexity of the case, but I offer free consultations to discuss expected costs upfront.

    5. Do criminal cases go on my permanent record?

    Many do. Proper legal intervention can sometimes prevent this through dismissals or negotiations.

    6. Will I have to go to trial?

    Not always. Many cases are resolved through negotiation, but I am fully prepared to take your case to trial if necessary.

    Prescott Criminal Case Stages:

    Acquiring a deeper understanding of the criminal trial process can provide a sense of reassurance for defendants. It equips you with the knowledge necessary to navigate the various stages of your case and comprehend the procedures involved. Our experienced criminal defense lawyers in Prescott are dedicated to guiding you through the entire process, offering comprehensive explanations and addressing any queries you may have along the way.

    1. Initial appearance and hearing: Following your arrest, you will attend an initial appearance before a judge. During this hearing, the judge will determine the conditions of your release or imprisonment. Subsequently, at a later date, you will participate in an arraignment hearing. Here, you will be formally charged and given the opportunity to enter a plea.
    2. Pre-trial negotiations: Prior to your trial in Prescott, you and your attorney will engage in negotiations with the prosecution, aiming to reach a resolution. If your attorney recommends accepting a plea deal, this may mark the culmination of your case. However, if your case proceeds to trial, you will proceed to the next phase.
    3. Trial: Every criminal trial commences with jury selection, followed by opening statements from both sides. The trial will then proceed to the presentation of evidence and witnesses by each party to establish their respective cases. Both sides will have the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses. The trial will conclude with closing statements, after which the jury will deliberate.
    4. Verdict: The jury will consider the evidence presented during the trial and deliberate on whether the prosecution has proven the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If the jury reaches a unanimous decision, they will provide a guilty or not-guilty verdict. In the event of a hung jury, where a unanimous decision cannot be reached, the judge may dismiss the case or declare a mistrial.
    5. Sentencing hearing: If the jury delivers a guilty verdict, you will await a sentencing hearing while in custody. During this final hearing, the judge will announce the sentence for the crimes of which you were convicted. Your attorney may explore the possibility of an appeal, if applicable.

    Your Prescott criminal defense attorney will ensure you are adequately prepared for each phase of the criminal trial process. From filing motions for dismissal to representing you in court, your attorney will facilitate each step, making the entire process more manageable for you.

    AREAS OF PRACTICE

    Criminal Lawyer in Prescott, AZ

    With my background I possess the experience and knowledge to proficiently handle your criminal or DUI case. Over the course of my career, I have successfully represented numerous clients and skillfully managed a diverse array of cases, encompassing various charges such as DUI, traffic offenses, drug-related allegations, and serious felonies. Irrespective of the complexity of your situation, my unwavering dedication lies in fighting for your rights. I am genuinely passionate about advocating for my clients and striving for the best possible outcomes in every case. Entrust your Criminal or DUI case to our accomplished Prescott Criminal Defense attorney, who will deftly navigate the intricacies and anxieties associated with your legal matter. You can have complete confidence that you are in capable hands, as our team is a highly experienced criminal defense staff.

    For a free consultation, contact our criminal defense team at TedLaw in Prescott Valley, AZ. Come prepared with your questions about our expertise, similar cases we’ve handled, and recommended next steps. We are dedicated to serving clients in their time of need and providing attentive listening, honest answers, and respectful treatment. Trust us to be your advocate and guide throughout the legal process.